Fixed written quotes · No hourly billingAtlanta, GA · Serving All USIntuit ProAdvisor Gold
(877) 290-4522 · [email protected]
(877) 290-4522Begin an Enquiry
Payroll

2% Shareholder Health Insurance on the W-2: Box 1 vs Boxes 3 and 5, and How to Record It in QuickBooks Payroll Before Year-End

Need this handled instead of explained? Talk to a US-based, Intuit ProAdvisor Gold team — (877) 290-4522 or [email protected]. Books a mess? Start with the free QuickBooks File Analyzer — 60 seconds, no signup.

If your S corporation pays health insurance premiums for a shareholder who owns more than 2% of the company, those premiums go on that shareholder’s Form W-2 as wages in box 1 and are subject to federal income tax withholding, but they stay out of boxes 3 and 5 and are not subject to social security, Medicare or FUTA, provided the plan covers all employees or a class of employees. The premiums have to be on the W-2 for the shareholder to take the self-employed health insurance deduction. In QuickBooks that means a dedicated S-corp medical item recorded before the year’s W-2s are produced. Here is the rule, a worked example, and the steps in QuickBooks Workforce and Desktop Payroll.

Ram Singh · Published November 17, 2026

Who counts as a 2% shareholder

The IRS defines a 2-percent shareholder as someone who owns more than 2% of the outstanding stock, or stock with more than 2% of the total combined voting power. In a typical one- or two-owner S corporation, every owner-employee is one. For ordinary employees, employer-paid health premiums are excluded from wages; for these shareholders they are not, which is why the treatment surprises people the first year they run payroll.

Box 1 vs boxes 3 and 5: where the premiums go

W-2 box / taxPlan covers all or a class of employeesNo such plan
Box 1 wages and federal income tax withholdingIncludedIncluded
Boxes 3 and 5 (social security and Medicare wages)ExcludedThe exclusion does not apply; Intuit treats it as fully taxable
FUTAExcludedFully taxable (Intuit)
S corporation deductionDeductibleConfirm with your CPA

The first column is from the IRS page “S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues” (reviewed March 3, 2026) and Publication 15 (2026). The FICA exclusion depends on the premiums being paid “under a plan or system that makes provision for all or a class of employees”; the second column reflects how Intuit’s payroll products classify the other case.

Company-paid policy vs a policy in the shareholder’s own name

Some states do not let a corporation buy group coverage for a single employee, so the owner buys a policy personally. IRS Notice 2008-1, as the IRS summarizes it, settles what happens next:

The IRS’s bottom line is that the premiums must ultimately be paid by the S corporation and reported as taxable compensation on the shareholder’s W-2. The deduction also is not available if the shareholder or spouse was eligible for a subsidized plan elsewhere. In the books, reimbursements to the owner should be recorded as premiums paid by the company, not as distributions; our S corp catch-up guide shows how to sort owner transactions into wages, distributions and loans.

A worked example

These figures are illustrative. A sole shareholder-employee is paid a $60,000 salary through payroll, and the S corporation pays $12,000 of health premiums for her during the year under a plan that covers its employees. Her W-2 should show:

If the premiums were wrongly run as ordinary wages, social security and Medicare would be charged on the extra $12,000: 7.65% each for her and the company, or $918 apiece. If they were left off the W-2 entirely, box 1 is understated by $12,000 and she loses the basis for her health insurance deduction. Both mistakes are easier to avoid in December than to correct after January; if a W-2 has already gone to the SSA, the fix is a Form W-2c, covered in W-2c vs a corrected W-2.

Setting it up in QuickBooks

Intuit’s article “Set up an S-corp medical payroll item for your corporate officers” (updated August 3, 2026) gives these steps.

QuickBooks Workforce (QuickBooks Online payroll), for shareholders on the same plan as other employees:

  1. Go to Payroll > Employees, select the shareholder, then Job & pay.
  2. Under Additional pay types, select Add and choose S-Corp Owners Health Insurance.
  3. Enter the recurring amount per paycheck, with start and end dates if needed, and save.

If the premiums were not tracked through the year, Workforce has a Fringe benefits only option in the Run payroll dropdown to record the total on one payroll, where you choose whether the business or the employee pays the taxes. If the employee pays and the check has no wages to cover it, QuickBooks records an employee tax loan, which Intuit says must be repaid by April 15 of the following year. Intuit states that Workforce does not support shareholders on a different plan, or where no plan is offered to employees; that case is handled only in Desktop Payroll.

QuickBooks Desktop Payroll:

  1. Create a Company Contribution payroll item (Lists > Payroll Item List > New > Custom Setup > Company Contribution), choose the liability and expense accounts, and set the tax tracking type to SCorp Pd Med Premium for a plan shared with employees, or Fringe Benefits for a different plan, which is fully taxable.
  2. Add the item to the shareholder in Employee Center > Payroll Info with the amount per paycheck and the annual limit.
  3. For a shareholder who will not be paid again this year, Intuit describes an unscheduled payroll with a zero net paycheck carrying the total premiums. Desktop Payroll Assisted users send that check to Intuit.

Intuit says both Desktop tax tracking types also show in box 14 of the W-2.

Year-end checklist for this item

  1. Pull the year’s premium invoices and any reimbursements to the shareholder, and total what the company actually paid.
  2. Compare that total with the S-corp medical item in the payroll summary report. Record any gap before the last payroll of the year.
  3. Preview the W-2: box 1 should exceed boxes 3 and 5 by the premiums (other pre-tax items aside).
  4. Give your CPA the premium total, which policy it was and in whose name, so the 1120-S and the shareholder’s return agree.

This sits alongside the other owner-pay checks in our owner and officer compensation guide. If you want it handled, our payroll team can set up the item and prepare the year-end entries.

This article is general bookkeeping information, not tax advice. Confirm your situation with your CPA and check irs.gov for any change after this date. Sources: IRS, “S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues” (reviewed March 3, 2026), Publication 15 (2026) and General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3 (2026), read November 17, 2026; Intuit, “Set up an S-corp medical payroll item for your corporate officers” (updated August 3, 2026).

Frequently asked questions

Does 2% shareholder health insurance go in box 1 of the W-2?
Yes. Premiums the S corporation pays for a more-than-2% shareholder-employee are reported as wages in box 1 and are subject to income tax withholding.

Are the premiums subject to social security and Medicare?
Not if they are paid under a plan that covers all employees or a class of employees. In that case they are left out of boxes 3 and 5 and are not subject to FUTA.

What if the owner bought the policy personally?
The S corporation should pay the insurer directly or reimburse the owner and include the premiums on the W-2. If the owner pays with personal funds and is not reimbursed, the IRS says the above-the-line deduction is not allowed.

How do I add S corp health insurance in QuickBooks Online payroll?
Add the S-Corp Owners Health Insurance pay type under the employee’s Job & pay, Additional pay types, or record a year-to-date total with a Fringe benefits only payroll.

Need this handled instead of explained? Talk to a US-based, Intuit ProAdvisor Gold team — (877) 290-4522 or [email protected]. Books a mess? Start with the free QuickBooks File Analyzer — 60 seconds, no signup.
Begin

Get a free scoping call.

Tell us what you’re working on. We respond same business day.

Ram Singh, Founder of Numerawise Solutions
Of the Author

Ram Singh · Founder & Principal

Founder of Numerawise Solutions, based in Atlanta. Intuit ProAdvisor Gold tier. Former Intuit Technical Support engineer. Has personally led two hundred accounting software conversions for US small businesses since founding the practice. Reachable directly at [email protected].

Related: Year-end payroll checklist · Switching payroll providers · Payroll